Page of Hopes surprisingly didn’t do well at all.Inaniloquacity took second place again, and was again not very close to the front-runner but still better than the other quizzes.Are fans reluctant to disregard the canon Homestuck/Hiveswap quiz created by Andrew Hussie himself? Or did the most diehard EZ-haters see that the EZ was a required question of this survey and refuse to take it at all? The world may never know. Not only was the EZ the most accurate, it was also the least incorrect of all the quizzes and didn’t receive a single “HAHA what the FUCK?” response.

Split that up among all the fan quizzes over the last ten years and it’s obvious that the EZ has the advantage. From the same survey, only 15% chose a classpect based on other fan quizzes. That’s pretty high! So these results are likely skewed because the EZ may be the cause of someone’s classpect, rather than its quiz result being a mere effect of that person’s classpect and quiz responses. survey helps a bit - it found that about 27% of their survey-takers let the result of the EZ quiz choose their classpect. The Extended Zodiac won in aspect accuracy by a landslide, and I wish I asked more questions to find out why.

homestuckexamination’s Mythological Class Test was pretty good at finding results that were close to accurate, but also had the fewest number of exactly correct results.

Second up is inaniloquacity’s MBTI-based class test, but that doesn’t seem to mean much - less than ½ of inaniloquacity’s quiz-takers got a class that they felt was accurate or close to accurate.

Page of Hope’s Enneagram-based class test is more accurate by a wide margin… as long as you don’t get one of the six fan classes, which unfortunately excludes about 1/3 of the population.In the time since I made these observations about quiz accuracy, the trends have pretty much solidified. Tl dr When comparing quizzes to each other, the most accurate aspect test is the Extended Zodiac (by quite a wide margin) and the most accurate class test is either Page of Hopes (except fan classes) or inaniloquacity. I think this will be about my final analysis on this test, unless I get a ton of new responses.

Hiveswap extended zodiac quiz